Arellano: L.A. Couple Faces Familiar Debate After Dodgers Win

In the heart of Wisconsin's state capital, where autumn leaves paint the streets in shades of orange and the air is filled with the spirit of the University of Wisconsin Badgers, a complex debate about loyalty and activism unfolded in the home of Carolina Sarmiento and Revel Sims. These urban planning professors, originally from Southern California—Sims from Eagle Rock and Sarmiento from Santa Ana—have called Madison their home for a decade. Yet, their commitment to immigrant and anti-gentrification causes remains strong, as they continue to engage in activism back in their hometown.

During a recent visit as part of a speaking tour across Midwestern colleges, I found myself caught in a conversation that resonated with many of our shared experiences. The topic was simple yet profound: Is it acceptable to celebrate the 2025 World Series victory of the Los Angeles Dodgers?

On one side, the Dodgers achieved a historic milestone by winning back-to-back titles for the first time in their history. This success symbolized the best of Los Angeles—a city known for its diversity and resilience. However, this year also marked a period of immense struggle for the city, including devastating wildfires and the escalating threat of mass deportations under the Trump administration.

For Sarmiento and other fans, the team’s actions during this time were difficult to reconcile. She expressed her disappointment with the Dodgers’ decision to visit the White House, particularly highlighting Mookie Betts’ attendance this year after previously declining when he was with the Boston Red Sox. “Who got in his ear?” she questioned, emphasizing the importance of standing up for justice over personal convenience.

Sarmiento, who wasn’t always a Dodger fan, became one after meeting Sims. They often attended games together, and even had a memorable encounter with manager Dave Roberts, who signed a jersey for them. But now, her support has wavered. “I tell Revel, ‘Babe, I’m not asking you to boycott the Dodgers forever, but they gotta give us something back.’”

The team did take some steps, such as blocking federal agents from entering Dodger Stadium after immigration raids and donating $1 million to support affected families. However, Sarmiento felt that these gestures were insufficient. She pointed out that only Kiké Hernández spoke out against the administration’s policies, while others remained silent.

Sims, too, felt conflicted about supporting the team this year. He acknowledged the historical obligation of the Dodgers to speak out on issues affecting their fan base. “It would’ve been easy for them to make a statement about their diverse fanbase,” he said. Yet, the lack of action left him feeling disconnected.

Despite this, not rooting for the Dodgers was never an option. “I want to see L.A. people happy. The parade! It’s a free holiday. People just ditch work and don’t get in trouble for it. We’re the only city—with a chant against us,” Sims remarked.

Sarmiento chimed in, “She’s my better political half,” Sims joked. “Caro said to pick another sport.” “No I didn’t!” she replied. “I just said to take a pause, just for now. A political pause.”

Sims admitted that his vintage jacket, once a symbol of his love for the team, remained in the closet. “I haven’t worn any gear all year,” he confessed. “When you went to the game!” Sarmiento shot back, referring to a recent visit to Milwaukee with his local softball team.

“I went with a Valenzuela jersey to represent L.A.,” Sims responded as Sarmiento shook her head. He laughed. “I love the team. I just don’t like this team for not saying anything. But it’s what I signed up for.”